Sued by Encore Capital Group in Pennsylvania? Here's What to Do Next

2015 · consent order

$52M+ total ($42M consumer refunds + $10M CFPB civil money penalty), plus order to stop collection on $125M+ in debts

CFPB consent order against Encore Capital Group, Midland Funding, Midland Credit Management, and Asset Acceptance finding the companies attempted to collect debts they didn't own or that were inaccurate, relied on robo-signed affidavits in court, and pressured consumers with misrepresentations about lawsuits. The order required documentation before filing suit and disclosures when collecting on time-barred debt.

CFPB source

2020 · lawsuit settled

$15M CFPB civil money penalty + $79,308.81 consumer redress; extended 2015 order conduct provisions for five additional years

CFPB filed suit and reached a stipulated settlement finding Encore and its subsidiaries violated the 2015 consent order by suing consumers without possessing required documentation, failing to provide required disclosures when consumers requested loan documentation, and suing on debts whose statutes of limitations had expired in violation of the FDCPA and CFPA.

CFPB source

Statute of Limitations Defense

In Pennsylvania, the statute of limitations for credit card debt is 4 years. If your last payment was more than 4 years ago, the debt is time-barred. Encore Capital Group has been the subject of CFPB findings related to suing on time-barred debts — check your dates carefully and raise the SOL defense in your Answer.

Lack of Standing / Chain of Title

As a debt buyer, Encore Capital Group must prove they actually purchased your specific account. Demand the complete chain of title — the purchase agreement, bill of sale, and assignment documents. In Pennsylvania courts, failing to produce this documentation can result in dismissal.

Challenge the Amount

Demand a complete accounting from the original creditor's last statement through the current claimed balance. Any unauthorized fees, post-charge-off interest, or collection costs not in the original agreement should be disputed line by line.

Pennsylvania Fair Credit Extension Uniformity Act / PA Unfair Trade Practices Act

In addition to the federal FDCPA, Pennsylvania's Pennsylvania Fair Credit Extension Uniformity Act / PA Unfair Trade Practices Act may provide additional protections and remedies against Encore Capital Group's collection practices.

Pennsylvania Court System

Magisterial district court up to $12,000. Court of common pleas for larger amounts. Filing fees in Pennsylvania typically range $45-$250.

What is Encore Capital Group?

Encore Capital Group is the largest publicly traded debt buyer in the U.S. They own LVNV Funding LLC and Midland Credit Management. If you are sued by either, Encore is the parent company.

Has the CFPB taken action against Encore?

Yes. The CFPB has ordered Encore subsidiaries to pay millions in fines and restitution for illegal debt collection practices including suing without proper documentation and collecting on time-barred debts.

Can I sue Encore Capital Group?

You would typically sue the subsidiary that contacted you (LVNV Funding or Midland Credit Management), but in some cases the parent company may also be liable for directing illegal collection practices.

How does Encore get my debt?

Encore purchases portfolios of thousands of defaulted accounts from banks and credit card companies, usually for 3-5 cents per dollar. They then attempt to collect the full original balance plus interest and fees.

How long to respond in Pennsylvania?

20 days from service to file your Answer.

What is the SOL in Pennsylvania?

4 years for all contract types including credit cards.

Can they garnish my wages in Pennsylvania?

No. Pennsylvania prohibits wage garnishment for most consumer debts. They can still levy bank accounts and place liens on property after getting a judgment.

What makes PA unique for debt defense?

The combination of a 4-year SOL and no wage garnishment makes Pennsylvania one of the most consumer-friendly states for debt defense.

Where are debt cases filed in PA?

Magisterial district court for smaller cases (up to $12,000). Court of common pleas for larger amounts.

Can a credit card company garnish my wages in Pennsylvania?

Almost never. Pennsylvania is one of the most consumer-protective states in the country on this issue. Under 42 Pa. C.S. § 8127, wages and salary earned for personal services are generally exempt from execution to satisfy a money judgment from an ordinary creditor like a credit card company or medical provider. The exceptions are narrow and include support orders, certain back rent for a residential lease, taxes, criminal restitution, and federal student loans. A debt buyer or original creditor who wins a Pennsylvania state court judgment on a credit card debt cannot use that judgment to garnish your paycheck. They can still try to levy on bank accounts, place liens on real property, and use the judgment as leverage. If a collector threatens to garnish your wages in Pennsylvania over a credit card or medical debt, that threat itself may violate the federal FDCPA and the FCEUA, since the collector cannot lawfully follow through. Get the threat in writing if possible and save it for a counterclaim or complaint.

What is the Pennsylvania FCEUA and how is it different from the FDCPA?

The Fair Credit Extension Uniformity Act at 73 P.S. § 2270.1 et seq. is Pennsylvania's state version of the federal FDCPA, with one major improvement for consumers. The federal FDCPA only applies to third-party debt collectors and debt buyers, not to original creditors collecting their own debts. The FCEUA expressly applies to creditors as well as collectors, which means if your original bank is the one making the abusive calls or false statements, you still have a state law claim even though federal FDCPA may not reach them. The FCEUA also makes any violation of its provisions an unfair or deceptive act under the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law (UTPCPL). The UTPCPL allows a private right of action for the greater of actual damages or $100, plus attorney fees, and in cases of willful conduct, treble damages. Stacking FCEUA, UTPCPL, and federal FDCPA claims can produce a meaningful counterclaim in a debt buyer suit.

How does a Magisterial District Judge case work in Pennsylvania for a debt collection lawsuit?

Most Pennsylvania consumer debt suits under $12,000 are filed before a Magisterial District Judge, the local-level court formerly called the District Justice. The process is informal, designed for self-represented litigants. You will receive a complaint and a hearing notice giving you a specific date and time. You do not need to file a written answer in advance; you appear, present your side, and the judge rules. Bring all documents you have: the complaint, any letters from the collector, payment records, and any communications. Make the plaintiff prove they own the debt by demanding to see the bill of sale and chain of assignments. If you lose at the MDJ level, you can file an appeal to the Court of Common Pleas within 30 days, which essentially restarts the case in a more formal court with full discovery and motion practice. The appeal is a do-over, not a review of the MDJ decision. Many debt buyers will not follow the case up on appeal, so an appeal can be a powerful tool.

I have an old judgment from a Pennsylvania court. How long does it last?

A Pennsylvania judgment is generally valid for five years from the date of entry and can be revived for additional five-year periods under 42 Pa. C.S. § 5526, potentially extending the judgment for many years. A judgment can be enforced by various means short of wage garnishment, including bank levies, real estate liens, and personal property executions. If your judgment is approaching the five-year mark, the creditor must take affirmative steps to revive it, and they often miss that deadline. If a judgment has not been revived in time, the creditor's ability to execute on it is significantly weakened. If you are dealing with an old judgment, the first step is to pull a current docket from the court website and confirm the entry date and any revivals. Sometimes the creditor or debt buyer is willing to settle a stale judgment for cents on the dollar because they fear losing enforceability. Consult a consumer attorney before paying or signing anything that might be construed as an acknowledgment that restarts the clock.

What is the statute of limitations on credit card debt in Pennsylvania?

Pennsylvania applies a four-year statute of limitations to actions on credit card and other contract debts under 42 Pa. C.S. § 5525. The clock generally starts on the date of the first missed payment that was never cured. Once four years have passed without a payment or written acknowledgment, the debt is generally time-barred. For installment loans, courts sometimes apply the four-year period to each missed installment, although most lenders accelerate the full balance once the loan is in default, which can start the clock running on the entire balance. Making even a small partial payment or signing a new agreement on an old debt can restart the clock under Pennsylvania law, so do not pay anything on an old debt without legal advice. If a debt buyer files suit in Pennsylvania on a credit card debt and the last payment was more than four years ago, raise the statute of limitations as an affirmative defense in your answer. Pennsylvania courts routinely dismiss time-barred debt buyer suits when the defense is properly raised.